Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ed Briggs's avatar

I didn't know Seidel's work, there's a lot I don't know, but very much enjoyed your to and fro about this latest collection and other work by him. Despite your only occasional smile in his direction and your mutual repulsion, your comments have induced me to want to buy a copy, just to see for myself. So thanks for that. Best, EB

Jem's avatar

I think you have his number here. Ten years ago I thought Seidel was important and exciting. He was always in the LRB, which was the kind of thing I cared about: that dynamic partly explains why you don't find anyone criticising him, people want to seem 'in the know'. I still think he sometimes pulls it off, when he's vulnerable or really commits to an image. I enjoy the way he breaks form, but sometimes it's just ugly. And yes that constant need to shock gets tiring and usually ruins the poems. I don't have any desire to read them anymore.

3 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?